A £60bn Tax Gap Is Driving HMRC’s Push For Unprecedented Surveillance And Penalty Powers

A shortfall of nearly £60bn in uncollected tax during the 2024/25 financial year is reshaping how Britain’s tax authority pursues revenue from ordinary citizens.

With Chancellor John Healey barred by Labour’s manifesto from raising income tax, VAT or employee national insurance, HMRC is being armed with a sweeping set of new enforcement tools instead.

Buried within the Finance Bill’s Budget Resolutions, which cleared their first parliamentary reading on 3 November, are measures that tax professionals say go well beyond routine modernisation.

Among the most striking proposals is a plan to extend the definition of digital records that HMRC can access to include conversations between taxpayers and AI chatbots.

Matthew Greene, a partner at Stewarts, warned that the power “also risks dragging innocent taxpayers into unnecessary investigations,” noting that “people may use AI to explore hypothetical tax arrangements without ever acting on them.”

Praveen Gupta, head of tax at Azets, argued that “without the right checks and balances HMRC’s new powers could cross the line between a legitimate investigation and overreach,” adding that robust safeguards would be critical to ensure requests remained relevant and proportionate.

HMRC insists the move is narrow in scope, with a spokesperson saying: “It is not about going through everyone’s use of large language models. We can only request information where we already have a lawful basis to do so.”

The Bill also removes any time limit on how long after a person’s death HMRC can pursue their estate for unpaid tax, replacing the current four-year cap with an unlimited window.

Families could find themselves contacted years after an estate has been fully settled, with advisers warning this risks disputes among relatives and unaffordable bills for those who have already distributed inherited assets.

Applications to a tax tribunal will be required before demands are issued beyond the four-year mark, though executors and family members will not be told until after the tribunal has reached its decision.

Perhaps the most contentious change for working taxpayers is a new statutory Duty to Correct regime, taking effect from April 2028, which will reclassify even accidental errors on old tax returns as “deliberate” if not corrected once identified.

Under current rules, an honest filing mistake is treated as careless, attracting a penalty of up to 30 per cent of unpaid tax across a six-year window, but the new framework could impose fines of up to 100 per cent and a scrutiny period stretching back two decades.

Tax barristers have raised particular concern about the 20-year lookback, since self-employed individuals are only legally required to retain financial records for five to six years, leaving many potentially unable to defend themselves against historic queries.

Fiona Fernie, partner at Blick Rothenberg, said: “This legislation needs clearer safeguards and a finite time limit for making corrections. Otherwise, a measure intended to modernise compliance could undermine it.”

Whistleblowers who report tax evasion to HMRC will also see their payouts restructured from March 2027, with the authority deducting 45 per cent income tax at source rather than paying the full reward and leaving recipients to settle their own liability.

Those tipping off HMRC under its Strengthened Reward Scheme, which requires a minimum of £1.5m in recovered tax to qualify and pays between 15 and 30 per cent of the sum collected, will receive 55 per cent of their gross award upfront under the new arrangement.

Separately, the tax authority appears to have quietly reversed a five-year policy of accepting electronic signatures on 64-8 authorisation forms, now demanding ink originals without having issued any formal guidance on the change.

Joseph Adunse, tax partner at Moore Kingston Smith, said the reversal “is affecting both self-assessment registration and tax agent authorisation and has been done without warning or explanation,” calling it a step backwards that makes compliance harder rather than simpler.

Healey has described restoring fiscal discipline as his “first commitment as Chancellor,” including “raising revenue from those who can afford to pay,” though critics argue several of the new measures reach far beyond the most affluent taxpayers.