Two High-Yield Stocks That Could Turn A Full ISA Into £1,675 Of Annual Income

A £20,000 Stocks and Shares ISA split equally between two listed income plays could generate roughly £1,675 a year, based on their estimated forward dividend yields.

That headline figure of approximately 8.4% blended yield comes from combining Ithaca Energy (LSE: ITH) and TwentyFour Income Fund (LSE: TFIF), two very different businesses united by double-digit trailing yields.

The annual ISA allowance of £20,000 shelters investment returns from tax, making the income from high-yielding shares considerably more valuable to investors than it would otherwise be.

TwentyFour Income Fund, a FTSE 250 investment trust, pools asset-backed securities including mortgage bundles, consumer loan packages, and collateralised loan obligations, distributing the interest generated to shareholders.

Its trailing yield stands at 10.45%, though the more reliable guide may be its annual target dividend of 8p per share, paid in quarterly instalments of 2p, pointing to a forward yield closer to 7.5%.

The trust’s share price has slipped 5.5% over the past year and 6.5% across five years, but those figures exclude reinvested dividends, which transform the picture considerably.

A £5,000 position taken five years ago would have grown to around £7,445 once dividends are included, representing a total return of 48.9%, and the shares currently trade at a 1.89% premium to net asset value.

Risks for TFIF include borrowers defaulting on underlying loans, declining asset valuations, difficulty selling less liquid securities during periods of market stress, and the prospect that falling interest rates erode income from its floating-rate holdings.

Ithaca Energy, the North Sea oil and gas producer that joined the FTSE 100 after floating in London in 2022, carries a trailing yield of 10.56% and a forward yield of around 9.2%, with shares up 20% over five years and 8.5% over the past twelve months.

The company has committed to returning 30% of post-tax operating cash flow to shareholders during 2026, with a target distribution range of 20% to 35% in subsequent years, meaning payouts will track cash generation rather than being set at a fixed level.

At a price-to-earnings ratio of approximately 18.5x, the valuation is not obviously cheap, and a significant political risk hangs over the stock in the form of the Rosebank oilfield decision.

Ithaca holds a 20% stake in Rosebank, and a government refusal to back the North Sea project could weigh on the share price, while approval could provide a swift uplift.

The company’s board has warned that a negative decision on Rosebank could prompt a reassessment of future investment in the United Kingdom, adding a layer of strategic uncertainty for shareholders.

Splitting a full £20,000 ISA allocation equally between the two would, on forward yield estimates, produce roughly £920 annually from the Ithaca position and approximately £755 from TwentyFour, before any changes to dividends or share prices.

For investors who find the Rosebank overhang too uncomfortable, TwentyFour Income Fund may represent the more dependable income foundation of the two, even if its double-digit trailing yield is unlikely to be sustained in perpetuity.