California Law Strips Plaintiffs Of Power To Sue Over Website Tracking Devices, Handing Businesses A Litigation Shield

A wave of privacy lawsuits targeting website cookies, pixels, and session-replay tools is about to recede sharply in California, reshaping the legal exposure for thousands of companies operating online.

Governor Gavin Newsom signed SB 690 on September 30, 2026, a measure that removes the ability of private individuals to bring claims under the pen register and trap-and-trace provisions of the California Invasion of Privacy Act.

From January 1, 2027, enforcement of those provisions will rest exclusively with the California Attorney General, ending years of high-volume litigation brought by plaintiffs and their counsel across the state.

The change targets Section 638.51 of CIPA, which bars anyone from installing or using a pen register or trap-and-trace device without first securing a court order.

California courts had gradually expanded that definition to cover common digital tools, ruling that software such as cookies and third-party tracking pixels could fall within the statutory language.

That interpretation opened the door to prolific litigation, with businesses across industries facing claims that routine analytics and advertising technologies amounted to illegal surveillance under state law.

SB 690 amends Section 637.2 of CIPA so that any action alleging a violation of the pen register provisions arising from conduct on a website or mobile application can only be filed by the Attorney General.

Crucially, the new law carries a retroactive element, applying to pending claims in actions commenced during the two years prior to the operative date, meaning cases filed on or after January 1, 2025 fall within its reach.

Businesses currently defending active pen register or trap-and-trace litigation should assess whether those claims qualify under the retroactivity window and consider pursuing dismissal or another form of disposition.

Companies that have received demand letters citing Section 638.51 alongside other legal theories are also expected to find themselves in a considerably stronger negotiating position once the amendment takes effect.

However, SB 690 does not extend its protections across all of CIPA, leaving intact the private right of action under Section 631, the wiretapping provision, and Section 632, which covers the recording of confidential communications.

Plaintiffs who previously combined trap-and-trace allegations with wiretapping or eavesdropping claims retain the ability to pursue those remaining causes of action, meaning litigation over the same tracking technologies is unlikely to disappear entirely.

Federal claims, other state statutes, common law theories, and constitutional arguments related to internet tracking remain available avenues for plaintiffs, ensuring privacy litigation does not simply vanish from California’s dockets.

The reform arrives as wiretapping-related lawsuits have spread well beyond California over recent years, with courts in different jurisdictions taking inconsistent approaches to resolving claims about digital tracking tools.

For businesses monitoring their compliance posture, the practical effect from early 2027 should be a meaningful decline in the volume of pen register demand letters and newly filed trap-and-trace actions targeting their websites and apps.